Plan to make landlords improve draughtiest homes and boost energy efficiency for hundreds of thousands of tenants lay in tatters, say critics
Landlords must raise their homes’ energy efficiency to at least Band E. Photograph: Alamy
Tenants face missing out on energy bill savings after the government caved in to landlords’ demands by lowering a cap on the costs they face to upgrade Britain’s draughtiest homes.
Landlords must improve the energy efficiency of F- and G-rated homes from next April under new regulations designed to protect vulnerable tenants and cut carbon emissions.
But on Tuesday the government said the costs of the upgrade would be capped at £2,500, half what officials had originally told buy-to-let landlords to expect. The total energy bill savings is put at £337m less as a result.
The government’s own assessment warned that the lower cap means only 139,200 households in England and Wales will benefit from better insulation by April 2020. That is 121,000 fewer than if the cap was at £5,000.
Draughty homes targeted in UK climate change masterplan
“This could leave a gaping hole in the government’s plans to meet its own fuel poverty targets,” said Richard Twinn, policy adviser at the UK Green Building Council.
The Association for Conservation of Energy said the government had “missed a big opportunity” to improve the efficiency of thousands of homes.
Officials said the lower cap was necessary to protect owners by ensuring “that landlords of F and G rated private rented properties are not faced with an excessive cost burden”.
The government also said the changes were necessary because landlords’ access to finance for energy-saving measures had become harder since the policy was first proposed.
One green energy charity accused Theresa May of putting landlords’ interests ahead of tenants. Max Wakefield, a campaigner at 10:10 Climate Action, said: “The prime minister claims to be prioritising controlling domestic energy costs, but in reality policy is being designed to suit landlords.
“Hundreds of thousands of renters will now be left wondering when, if ever, they can expect to live in a decent home.”
But the National Landlords Association was not happy either, calling the proposal a “complete farce”. It said there was a risk landlords who still could not afford the upgrades would leave properties empty and unimproved.
“The government clearly thinks that landlords have cash to spare, just when its own changes to landlord taxation will soon be increasing the cost of providing homes to rent,” said Richard Lambert, the group’s chief executive.
There are around 267,000 private rental homes in England in the worst energy bands, F and G, with a further 13,000 in Wales.
Fuel poverty group National Energy Action said that 122,000 of those tenants in England were suffering the worst extremes of fuel poverty, paying over £1,000 more for electricity and gas than households not living in poverty.
Ed Davey, Liberal Democrat MP and the former energy minister who created the regulations, said the change undermined commitments made in the government’s recent climate change masterplan.
“The Clean Growth Strategy said it was taking fuel poverty and [energy] efficiency seriously. This looks like that was spin and not real,” he told the Guardian.
The Department for Business, Energy and Industrial Strategy said: “Our proposed changes send a clear signal to landlords that they need to improve the energy efficiency of homes they’re renting out.”